All the cool kids insist on having their birthday parties at this quaint Central Park theater, which specializes in puppet shows and holds up to 100 people. (It's also open to the public with tickets costing $7 for kids, $10 for adults.) After the show, the shorties head into a private party room (call for reservations), which has kid-size furniture, natch. Recent productions include a musical version of the J.M. Barrie classic Peter Pan and the Adventures in Neverland, complete with an amazing twist: it takes place in NYC.