Sal and Carmine

2671 Broadway
Manhattan, NY 10025
Upper West Side

  • Mon.–Sun., 11:30am–10pm

Sal and Carmine is another benchmark by which to judge a great New York slice. Like at Famous Joe's, the slice here is a study in understatement. The crust is properly thin, crisp and foldable, with just enough whole-fat mozzarella pulling away from your bite in melty strings. Sal and Carmine uses a hefty amount of Parmesan on the pizza, which adds plenty of flavor and just as much saltiness—some say too much. If you're salt-averse, you've been warned.



  • Cash Only
  • $

As Seen In...

Best Pizza Slices

Restaurants Best Pizza Slices

Who makes the best slice of pizza in all five boroughs? We aim to settle that argument in this roundup of New York City pizzerias: choose the style that suits your mood and start eating. You won't walk away hungry.


From Our Partners