Totonno’s Pizzeria Napolitano


1524 Neptune Ave
Brooklyn, NY 11224
Coney Island


Advertisement

“Only God makes better pizza,” boasts Zagat about this Brooklyn fixture, and its loyal fans seem to agree. In 1924, Anthony “Totonno” Pero opened his first pizzeria in Coney Island, and today, the same family runs this local favorite, which serves up coal-brick-oven pies composed of tomatoes imported from Italy, dough made fresh daily and the family’s secret blend of spices. There are appetizers, pasta and salads, too, but let’s be honest—everyone comes for the pizza.

Photo: Daniel Krieger
Advertisement

Features

  • Credit Cards Accepted
  • $$
  • Pizza

As Seen In...

What Is New York City Pizza?

Restaurants What Is New York City Pizza?

Everything you ever wanted to know about the semi-official food of New York City.

Types of NYC Pizza

Restaurants Types of NYC Pizza

Here's our guide to the major variations of NYC pizza.

Eat Your Way Through Coney Island

Restaurants Eat Your Way Through Coney Island

Enjoy hot dog, gelato and empanada vendors in NYC's playground.

11 Foods Only NYC Does Right

Restaurants 11 Foods Only NYC Does Right

It's the law: you have to eat all of these foods when you come to New York City.


Advertisement

From Our Partners

View All

More In Restaurants