Gotham Comedy Club 208 W. 23rd St., Chelsea, Manhattan At Gotham Comedy Club, native New Yorkers Chris Mazzilli and Michael Reisman bring the dignified air of an old-world supper club to the modern stand-up comedy scene. While the elegant theater is unusually cushy, once the comedians take the stage, you’ll realize that humor is truly Gotham’s main attraction. Comics range from up-and-coming talents to top headliners such as Lewis Black, Dane Cook and Dave Chappelle.