Peanut Butter & Co.

240 Sullivan St.
Manhattan, NY 10012

Greenwich Village


A sandwich shop unlike any other, this quirky Greenwich Village staple sells 12 different varieties of peanut butter sandwiches, including nontraditional options such as the Peanut Butter BLT and the Elvis, which is grilled with bananas and honey. Jars of the store’s famous specialty peanut butter flavors, like Mighty Maple and The Heat Is On, are also for sale online and on-site.



  • WiFi
  • Kid Friendly
  • $
  • American (Traditional)
  • Coffeehouse
  • Dessert
  • Historic Sites & Landmarks
  • Historic Sites


From Our Partners