These days Prince Street Pizza is a bit of an anomaly in NoLITa—a workaday slice shop nestled among tony boutiques and sit-down cafés. But Prince Street serves no ordinary slice, and it has the celebrity clientele to prove it (as witnessed by the gallery of framed photos that line the walls). The regular round pizzas here would be standouts anywhere else, but the thicker square pies and the slices that come from them are phenomenal and are the thing to get. Carnivores should absolutely steer toward the Spicy Spring, piled with crisp pepperoni, cupped to cradle pools of pepperoni oil. The Prince Perfection lives up to its name—a spot-on square slice topped first with mozzarella and then a tangy sauce atop the cheese (also known as an "upside-down" slice).